Skip to the content
Know your tech before you buy it. Makers: get listed from $49/mo
Industry Software

Best Nonprofit Payroll Software in 2026

Facts read from the makers 27 Sept 2026 – 18 Nov 2026

Sage Payroll leads this list of 29 (Club score 8.1). CDM+ is next (Club score 8.1), and Wave is the highest-placed with a free plan (Club score 8.0). Nonprofit payroll software helps organizations pay staff and contractors, handle tax filing, and track work time. The choice depends on the payroll features you need and the platforms your team uses.

Nonprofit Payroll Software: the Club's top 10

ProductWhat it doesClub scoreStartRuns onFacts checked
1 Sage Payroll—8.1Free trialWindows · macOS · Web · iPhone and iPad21 Oct 2026
2 CDM+CDM+ is fund-accounting and management software built for nonprofit and faith-based organizations.8.1Free trialWindows · macOS · Web · iPhone and iPad28 Sept 2026
3 WaveWave is invoicing software that helps businesses create and send invoices, receive payments, and manage customer information.8.0Free planWeb · iPhone and iPad · Android · API18 Nov 2026
4 HomebaseHomebase combines staff scheduling, time tracking and payroll with hiring, onboarding, HR, compliance and team communication for hourly teams.8.0Free planWeb · iPhone and iPad · Android · API18 Nov 2026
5 Employment HeroEmployment Hero is an HR service for employee records, time-off management, onboarding, performance management and time tracking.8.0Free planWeb · iPhone and iPad · Android · API18 Nov 2026
6 Payroll4FreePayroll4Free handles payroll for employees and 1099 contractors, with tax calculations, payment options, time tracking, employee access and reports.7.8Free planWindows · Web · Browser extension30 Sept 2026
7 Square Online—7.6Free planWeb8 Oct 2026
8 OnPayOnPay brings payroll, HR, benefits, and time tracking together for small businesses.7.6Free trialWeb · iPhone and iPad · Android · API18 Nov 2026
9 Patriot PayrollPatriot Payroll is an online payroll service for businesses with employees working in the United States.7.6Free trialWeb · iPhone and iPad · Android18 Nov 2026
10 WagepointWagepoint is payroll software for Canadian small businesses that pay employees and contractors.7.6Free trialWeb · iPhone and iPad · Android18 Nov 2026

Review free-plan availability, entry pricing, tax filing, nonprofit tax features, multi-state processing, contractor payments, employee caps, and timekeeping. Confirm support for browsers, Android, iOS, Windows, macOS, and APIs.

29 productsOrdered 22 Nov 2026 How the Club ranks

Ranked by the Club score: how fast a newcomer can get going, from what each maker publishes.

  1. 1

    Sage Payroll

    • Free trial
    • Windows · macOS · Web · iPhone and iPad
    8.1 Club score
  2. 2

    CDM+

    CDM+ is fund-accounting and management software built for nonprofit and faith-based organizations.

    • Free trial
    • Windows · macOS · Web · iPhone and iPad
    8.1 Club score
  3. 3

    Wave

    Wave is invoicing software that helps businesses create and send invoices, receive payments, and manage customer information.

    • Free plan
    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android · API
    8.0 Club score
  4. 4

    Homebase

    Homebase combines staff scheduling, time tracking and payroll with hiring, onboarding, HR, compliance and team communication for hourly teams.

    • Free plan
    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android · API
    8.0 Club score
  5. 5

    Employment Hero

    Employment Hero is an HR service for employee records, time-off management, onboarding, performance management and time tracking.

    • Free plan
    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android · API
    8.0 Club score
  6. 6

    Payroll4Free

    Payroll4Free handles payroll for employees and 1099 contractors, with tax calculations, payment options, time tracking, employee access and reports.

    • Free plan
    • Windows · Web · Browser extension
    7.8 Club score
  7. 7

    Square Online

    • Free plan
    • Web
    7.6 Club score
  8. 8

    OnPay

    OnPay brings payroll, HR, benefits, and time tracking together for small businesses.

    • Free trial
    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android · API
    7.6 Club score
  9. 9

    Patriot Payroll

    Patriot Payroll is an online payroll service for businesses with employees working in the United States.

    • Free trial
    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android
    7.6 Club score
  10. 10

    Wagepoint

    Wagepoint is payroll software for Canadian small businesses that pay employees and contractors.

    • Free trial
    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android
    7.6 Club score
  11. 11

    Knit Payroll

    Knit Payroll combines payroll, payments, and HR in a web platform for Canadian small businesses.

    • Free trial
    • Web · API
    7.4 Club score
  12. 12

    Realm

    Realm is church management software from ACS Technologies for pastors, staff, and congregations.

    • Free trial
    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android
    7.2 Club score
  13. 13

    QuickBooks Payroll

    • Free trial
    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android
    7.1 Club score
  14. 14

    Rippling

    Rippling is a human capital management system for managing employee records and the employee lifecycle, alongside HR, IT, finance and other workforce operations.

    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android · API
    7.1 Club score
  15. 15

    Gusto

    Gusto is a small business platform for payroll, benefits, and HR.

    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android · API
    7.1 Club score
  16. 16

    SurePayroll

    SurePayroll provides online payroll services for small businesses, solopreneurs, and households.

    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android
    7.1 Club score
  17. 17

    Dayforce Workforce Management

    Dayforce Workforce Management brings scheduling, time and attendance, labor planning, absence management, and task tools together for frontline teams.

    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android · API
    6.9 Club score
  18. 18

    Paycor

    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android · API
    6.9 Club score
  19. 19

    Paylocity

    Paylocity is an HR, payroll, and spend management platform that brings together tools for Human Resources, Finance, and IT.

    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android
    6.9 Club score
  20. 20

    Paycom

    Paycom is a cloud-based human capital management platform that combines payroll and HR.

    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android
    6.9 Club score
  21. 21

    Justworks Benefits

    Justworks Benefits provides employers with tools to administer benefits, from setup and new-hire enrollment to qualifying life events, deductions and COBRA…

    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android
    6.7 Club score
  22. 22

    ADP Workforce Now

    ADP Workforce Now is a web and mobile payroll and HR platform presented for organizations with 50–999 and 1,000 or more employees.

    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android
    6.7 Club score
  23. 23

    MIP Payroll

    MIP People is a cloud-based solution combining accounting, human resources, and payroll.

    • Windows · Web · Self-hosted
    6.7 Club score
  24. 24

    Workday Benefits

    Workday Benefits helps organizations administer employee benefit plans alongside employee data.

    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android · API
    6.6 Club score
  25. 25

    PayFWDs

    PayFWDs combines payroll, HR and timekeeping tools with support for businesses.

    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android
    6.5 Club score

Are free access or a trial available?

Look at each product's no-cost plan and trial terms. A free plan lets you continue without payment, while a trial gives temporary access.

Payroll4Free and Homebase have free plans. Patriot Payroll starts at $17 per month and lists a 30-day trial; OnPay starts at $49 per month.

Does it support nonprofit tax filing?

Review tax-filing features before choosing a payroll system, and verify any nonprofit-specific support your organization requires. These are separate comparison points, so confirm both for your organization.

Also check whether the software handles payroll across multiple states if your staff work in different locations.

Can it pay contractors as well as employees?

If your nonprofit hires contractors, verify that the product can pay them in addition to employees. Confirm this alongside employee payroll rather than assuming the feature is included.

Employee limits are another comparison point, especially when your organization expects its staff count to change.

Which platforms does it need to run on?

Choose a platform that matches how your team works.

All 30 listed products provide web access; 24 list Android support and 24 list iOS support. API access appears on 12, Windows on four, and macOS on two.

Does it include time tracking?

If staff hours feed into payroll, verify that the plan includes timekeeping. Treat it as a separate feature from payroll processing when comparing plans.

Questions about Nonprofit Payroll Software

Which nonprofit payroll products have no-cost plans?

Payroll4Free, Wave, Homebase, and Employment Hero are listed with free plans. Check the included payroll, tax, employee, and time-tracking features before choosing.

Which nonprofit payroll tools offer a free trial?

Patriot Payroll and Knit Payroll list 30-day trials. Homebase and Wagepoint list 14-day trials, while Realm lists a 30-day trial.

What price range is listed for nonprofit payroll software?

Listed starting prices include $15 per month for Payroll4Free, $17 for Patriot Payroll, $25 for CDM+, $30 for Homebase, and $49 for OnPay. Some makers quote pricing on request.

Is multi-state payroll available in nonprofit software?

Multi-state payroll is one of the category's comparison points. Check each product's details to confirm support for the states where your organization employs people.

Which devices and systems can run nonprofit payroll software?

The list covers web, Android, iOS, API, Windows, and macOS access. Every listed product supports the web, while the other options differ by product.