Skip to the content
Know your tech before you buy it. Makers: get listed from $49/mo
Industry Software

Best Church Payroll Software in 2026

Facts read from the makers 19 Sept 2026 – 18 Nov 2026

CDM+ leads this list of 27 (Club score 8.1). Church Windows is next (Club score 7.9). For churches, payroll tools may cover clergy pay, housing allowances, tax support, W-2 and 1099 forms, direct deposits, and payroll reports; compare these capabilities with pricing and platform coverage.

Church Payroll Software: the Club's top 10

ProductWhat it doesClub scoreStartRuns onFacts checked
1 CDM+CDM+ is fund-accounting and management software built for nonprofit and faith-based organizations.8.1Free trialWindows · macOS · Web · iPhone and iPad28 Sept 2026
2 Church WindowsChurch Windows provides church management modules for membership, scheduling, donations, accounting, and payroll.7.9Free trialWindows · macOS · Web · Self-hosted21 Oct 2026
3 OnPayOnPay brings payroll, HR, benefits, and time tracking together for small businesses.7.6Free trialWeb · iPhone and iPad · Android · API18 Nov 2026
4 Patriot PayrollPatriot Payroll is an online payroll service for businesses with employees working in the United States.7.6Free trialWeb · iPhone and iPad · Android18 Nov 2026
5 IconCMO PayrollIconCMO Payroll is payroll software for churches, designed to integrate with IconCMO fund accounting.7.6Free trialWeb · iPhone and iPad · Android · API15 Oct 2026
6 ParishSOFTParishSOFT provides church management software for Catholic parishes and dioceses, with tools for records, accounting, giving, and ministry operations.7.6Free trialWeb · iPhone and iPad · Android · API10 Oct 2026
7 FlockBaseFlockBase combines church membership management, contribution tracking, fund accounting, and payroll.7.2Free trialWindows · Web4 Oct 2026
8 RealmRealm is church management software from ACS Technologies for pastors, staff, and congregations.7.2Free trialWeb · iPhone and iPad · Android7 Oct 2026
9 QuickBooks Payroll—7.1Free trialWeb · iPhone and iPad · Android18 Nov 2026
10 isolved HCMisolved HCM, also called People Cloud, brings HR, payroll, benefits, and talent management into one platform with AI-powered automation and insights.7.1—Web · iPhone and iPad · Android · API15 Oct 2026

Review whether each option offers a no-cost plan or trial, its entry-level paid price, and compatibility with web, iOS, Android, API, Windows, or macOS.

27 productsOrdered 22 Nov 2026 How the Club ranks

Ranked by the Club score: how fast a newcomer can get going, from what each maker publishes.

  1. 1

    CDM+

    CDM+ is fund-accounting and management software built for nonprofit and faith-based organizations.

    • Free trial
    • Windows · macOS · Web · iPhone and iPad
    8.1 Club score
  2. 2

    Church Windows

    Church Windows provides church management modules for membership, scheduling, donations, accounting, and payroll.

    • Free trial
    • Windows · macOS · Web · Self-hosted
    7.9 Club score
  3. 3

    OnPay

    OnPay brings payroll, HR, benefits, and time tracking together for small businesses.

    • Free trial
    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android · API
    7.6 Club score
  4. 4

    Patriot Payroll

    Patriot Payroll is an online payroll service for businesses with employees working in the United States.

    • Free trial
    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android
    7.6 Club score
  5. 5

    IconCMO Payroll

    IconCMO Payroll is payroll software for churches, designed to integrate with IconCMO fund accounting.

    • Free trial
    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android · API
    7.6 Club score
  6. 6

    ParishSOFT

    ParishSOFT provides church management software for Catholic parishes and dioceses, with tools for records, accounting, giving, and ministry operations.

    • Free trial
    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android · API
    7.6 Club score
  7. 7

    FlockBase

    FlockBase combines church membership management, contribution tracking, fund accounting, and payroll.

    • Free trial
    • Windows · Web
    7.2 Club score
  8. 8

    Realm

    Realm is church management software from ACS Technologies for pastors, staff, and congregations.

    • Free trial
    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android
    7.2 Club score
  9. 9

    QuickBooks Payroll

    • Free trial
    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android
    7.1 Club score
  10. 10

    isolved HCM

    isolved HCM, also called People Cloud, brings HR, payroll, benefits, and talent management into one platform with AI-powered automation and insights.

    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android · API
    7.1 Club score
  11. 11

    Gusto

    Gusto is a small business platform for payroll, benefits, and HR.

    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android · API
    7.1 Club score
  12. 12

    SurePayroll

    SurePayroll provides online payroll services for small businesses, solopreneurs, and households.

    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android
    7.1 Club score
  13. 13

    Payroll Mate

    Payroll Mate is Windows desktop software for running payroll in-house, calculating pay and payroll taxes, and printing checks.

    • Free trial
    • Windows
    7.0 Club score
  14. 14

    Storehouse Finance

    • Free trial
    • Web
    6.9 Club score
  15. 15

    Paycor

    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android · API
    6.9 Club score
  16. 16

    Paylocity

    Paylocity is an HR, payroll, and spend management platform that brings together tools for Human Resources, Finance, and IT.

    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android
    6.9 Club score
  17. 17

    Paycom

    Paycom is a cloud-based human capital management platform that combines payroll and HR.

    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android
    6.9 Club score
  18. 18

    Amplify Accounting

    Amplify Accounting is a GAAP-compliant fund accounting solution built for churches and ministries.

    • Free trial
    6.8 Club score
  19. 19

    FellowshipOne

    FellowshipOne is church management software that brings together member information, communications, security, events, tasks, finances and reporting.

    • Windows · macOS · Web · iPhone and iPad
    6.7 Club score
  20. 20

    Elexio Church Accounting

    Elexio Church Accounting is web-based financial software for churches, ministries, nonprofits, and denominational headquarters.

    • Web
    6.7 Club score
  21. 21

    ADP Workforce Now

    ADP Workforce Now is a web and mobile payroll and HR platform presented for organizations with 50–999 and 1,000 or more employees.

    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android
    6.7 Club score
  22. 22

    CarbonHRM

    CarbonHRM provides HR, payroll, and reporting tools for churches, ministries, and non-profits.

    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android
    6.5 Club score
  23. 23 6.5 Club score
  24. 24

    Shelby Financials Payroll

    Shelby Financials Payroll is a payroll module for churches, ministries, nonprofits, and denominational headquarters.

    • Windows · Web
    6.4 Club score
  25. 25

    ACS General Ledger

    • Windows · Web
    5.4 Club score

Which payroll functions does it cover?

Begin with the listed capabilities: clergy compensation, housing allowances, tax filing, W-2 and 1099 forms, direct deposit, and payroll reports.

Use the feature fields to match the software to the payroll tasks your church needs to handle.

What will the paid plan cost?

Look for a published entry price, or ask the maker for a quote before subscribing.

Examples on the list are Church Windows at $19 per month, CDM+ at $25, IconCMO Payroll at $40, and OnPay at $49.

Can I try it before paying?

Check the free-plan and free-trial fields separately because a paid product can still offer a trial.

FlockBase lists a 14-day trial, Patriot Payroll a 30-day trial, Realm a 30-day trial, and Amplify Accounting a free trial.

Which platforms does it run on?

Select software that matches the systems your staff use, including web, iOS, Android, API, Windows, or macOS.

Web access is common across the category, while mobile, desktop, and API support vary by product.

Questions about Church Payroll Software

Does church payroll software handle clergy housing allowances?

Housing allowance appears as one of the comparison fields. Check each product's details to see whether it supports this need.

Which church payroll software supports W-2 and 1099 forms?

The comparison includes W-2 and 1099 capability. Review each product entry for the specific forms it supports.

Is there free church payroll software?

The list has no products with a free plan, so distinguish that field from trial availability. Products with paid pricing can still include a free trial.

What church payroll software works on a phone?

Phone access depends on platform support. Compare the iOS and Android fields for the products you are considering.

How much does church payroll software cost?

Listed starting prices are $17 per month for Patriot Payroll, $19 for Church Windows, $24 for FlockBase, $25 for CDM+, $40 for IconCMO Payroll, and $49 for OnPay; other products require a quote.