Skip to the content
Know your tech before you buy it. Makers: get listed from $49/mo
Instead of SurePayroll

Best SurePayroll Alternatives in 2026

Taken from Church Payroll Software, where SurePayroll is listed too, in the same order.

  1. 1

    CDM+

    CDM+ is fund-accounting and management software built for nonprofit and faith-based organizations.

    • Free trial
    • Windows · macOS · Web · iPhone and iPad
    8.1 Club score
  2. 2

    Church Windows

    Church Windows provides church management modules for membership, scheduling, donations, accounting, and payroll.

    • Free trial
    • Windows · macOS · Web · Self-hosted
    7.9 Club score
  3. 3

    OnPay

    OnPay brings payroll, HR, benefits, and time tracking together for small businesses.

    • Free trial
    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android · API
    7.6 Club score
  4. 4

    Patriot Payroll

    Patriot Payroll is an online payroll service for businesses with employees working in the United States.

    • Free trial
    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android
    7.6 Club score
  5. 5

    IconCMO Payroll

    IconCMO Payroll is payroll software for churches, designed to integrate with IconCMO fund accounting.

    • Free trial
    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android · API
    7.6 Club score
  6. 6

    ParishSOFT

    ParishSOFT provides church management software for Catholic parishes and dioceses, with tools for records, accounting, giving, and ministry operations.

    • Free trial
    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android · API
    7.6 Club score
  7. 7

    FlockBase

    FlockBase combines church membership management, contribution tracking, fund accounting, and payroll.

    • Free trial
    • Windows · Web
    7.2 Club score
  8. 8

    Realm

    Realm is church management software from ACS Technologies for pastors, staff, and congregations.

    • Free trial
    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android
    7.2 Club score
  9. 9

    QuickBooks Payroll

    • Free trial
    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android
    7.1 Club score
  10. 10

    isolved HCM

    isolved HCM, also called People Cloud, brings HR, payroll, benefits, and talent management into one platform with AI-powered automation and insights.

    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android · API
    7.1 Club score
  11. 11

    Gusto

    Gusto is a small business platform for payroll, benefits, and HR.

    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android · API
    7.1 Club score
  12. 12

    Payroll Mate

    Payroll Mate is Windows desktop software for running payroll in-house, calculating pay and payroll taxes, and printing checks.

    • Free trial
    • Windows
    7.0 Club score
  13. 13

    Storehouse Finance

    • Free trial
    • Web
    6.9 Club score
  14. 14

    Paycor

    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android · API
    6.9 Club score
  15. 15

    Paylocity

    Paylocity is an HR, payroll, and spend management platform that brings together tools for Human Resources, Finance, and IT.

    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android
    6.9 Club score
  16. 16

    Paycom

    Paycom is a cloud-based human capital management platform that combines payroll and HR.

    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android
    6.9 Club score
  17. 17

    Amplify Accounting

    Amplify Accounting is a GAAP-compliant fund accounting solution built for churches and ministries.

    • Free trial
    6.8 Club score
  18. 18

    FellowshipOne

    FellowshipOne is church management software that brings together member information, communications, security, events, tasks, finances and reporting.

    • Windows · macOS · Web · iPhone and iPad
    6.7 Club score
  19. 19

    Elexio Church Accounting

    Elexio Church Accounting is web-based financial software for churches, ministries, nonprofits, and denominational headquarters.

    • Web
    6.7 Club score
  20. 20

    ADP Workforce Now

    ADP Workforce Now is a web and mobile payroll and HR platform presented for organizations with 50–999 and 1,000 or more employees.

    • Web · iPhone and iPad · Android
    6.7 Club score

The whole list: Church Payroll Software